Celx-Requin's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Ultra Sheriff - Nemesis]

The marks of a true animator

This cartoon was really well done,
you seem to have the traits of a profesional animator.

You know how to play with timing, and you can fuse different mediums well (I think portions of this cartoon used some 3D program for the ships). You also know when to cheat (tweening instead of FBF animation).

I can't say anything too bad, except a menu with different options would have been nice, and extras would have been nicer...

Anyway keep up the good work, I'm sure you'll get an award for this.

Sincerely,
- Celx

UltraSheriff responds:

hey, and thanks for a very insightful review!
I was aiming to fuse different mediums, to boost my skills in afterfx and maya, wanted to push myself to make something in 3d, which i think is a powerful tool to know.
i have always felt that animation is to some extent about "cheating", saving time for those shots u really want to go to town with, and doing tweens and limited animation where you can.
as fo a menu, i quite agree, although im not sure what to put on it. i would say i like minimalism, but maybe im just lazy:)

[The Story of Peter]

Awful animation...

Awesome punchline!
You have an interesting style, and the music worked well.

My only complaints are, poor animation, & the preloader didn't work for me.
Anyway pretty cool short.

Sincerely,
- Celx

brianthemouse responds:

why do you do that

- celx

when i can already read your name on the by:Celx-Requin